Criminal justice reporting Interviewing investigative journalism Mayborn Literary Nonfiction Conference tech

Covering failures in the justice system with patience for facts and sensitivity to victims

Investigative reporter Pamela Colloff at the 2019 Mayborn Literary Nonfiction Conference with a session on avoiding exploitation when writing true crime stories. Colloff has written about some of the most egregious wrongful convictions and high-profile crimes in America.

Investigative reporter Pamela Colloff at the 2019 Mayborn Literary Nonfiction Convention with a session on avoiding exploitation when writing true crime tales. Colloff has written about a number of the most egregious wrongful convictions and high-profile crimes in America.
Sarah Stevens

Journalism that explores “true crime” is booming, in every thing from investigative stories to books to gripping TV documentaries. But it may possibly easily danger being exploitative.

That cautionary notice comes from Pamela Colloff, whose justice system reporting for Texas Month-to-month, and now ProPublica and The New York Occasions Journal, has garnered an extended record of awards. She is a six-time Nationwide Journal Award finalist, and gained in 2013 for “The Harmless Man,” a few man wrongly convicted of murdering his wife. Her 2010 story, “Innocence Misplaced,” was credited with liberating one other man who was on dying row.

Earlier this month, on the 2019 Mayborn Literary Nonfiction Convention, Colloff shared classes from her experience masking justice issues in a conversation with Laura Beil, an award-winning medical journalist who hosts the Dr. Dying podcast.

Colloff stated the perfect justice tales are informed with a considerate blend of care and sensitivity. For instance, she cited “An Unbelievable Story of Rape,” a Pulitzer Prize-winning narrative by Christian Miller of ProPublica and Ken Armstrong of The Marshall Undertaking, which is advised from the attitude of the victim.

Colloff prefaced her Mayborn remarks with an admission about her personal work: “I don’t all the time get this proper.” When embarking on a undertaking, she sets out to type a relationship with the subject of her story, who might be a survivor of a sexual assault, an inmate or a family member of a victim. That course of sometimes begins with a letter of introduction and rationalization of her intent to explore a narrative.

During interviews, she tries to be a sympathetic listener. She lets her subject information the move of the interview, how a lot is shared and when. This strategy provides her story topics a way of management and trust that may be so robust that they often confide details to her that they’ve only shared with few, if any, others.

…when you’re going to do the enterprise stuff, you need to study to be more of a storyteller.

Colloff stays in touch together with her subjects by way of the writing and modifying process and goes over sensitive material earlier than publication “so they can put together themselves for the public attention.” That also helps with fact-checking, she stated.

General, she is guided by one overriding thought: “It’s the large strain I feel to do a narrative justice. A real obligation to do good work.”

After her Mayborn speak, I received a bit of one-on-one time with Colloff to study more about her process, from conception to research and reporting and through the modifying and revising process. Here is a recap of our conversation, edited for length and clarity.

The place do your ideas come from? As you’ve develop into higher recognized, particularly on your tales about wrongful convictions, are individuals sending you ideas?

It’s totally different with every story. I do have extra individuals sending me stuff now, which is nice. One of many things that’s arduous a few wrongful conviction case is that even just evaluating if it’s value writing about can take months as a result of they’re so difficult.

  • She uses Google alerts:  I have upwards of 80 Google alerts going at all times, and I’m positive that one is going to pan out considered one of today. The Google alerts are often set to a state I’m concerned about writing about plus some felony justice concern I’m taking a look at. So it could possibly be Arkansas and Montana on the dying penalty — one thing like that.
  • She talks to a variety of legal professionals: The story concept they keep in mind won’t necessarily be the thought. But I’ll ask them about another issues and discover tales that means.
  • She finds ideas throughout her:  You recognize, your Uber driver, or whomever.  I wrote a narrative in 2015 referred to as “The Witness,” a few lady I knew who was the public info officer for the Texas Department of Felony Justice. She witnessed 278 executions, and she or he had been there once I was overlaying numerous other issues that had to do with the legal justice department or the demise penalty.

How do you pitch a story to your editors?

I’m not good with pitching stuff in individual. I all the time do a very detailed memo. The memo for the story I’m writing right now was three pages, single-spaced. And I should add that I’m pitching to my employers. If I have been doing a contract pitch, it will be totally different.

I often begin with a story prime and lay out the characters and the story arc and then get to why it’s necessary.

What’s your course of for research and reporting?

Larry Wright has his well-known index card system. I want I had one thing like that. I read a ton, particularly if I’m writing a few legal case. Trial transcripts. Warrants. News coverage at the time. I’ll make an inventory of these individuals I feel are almost definitely to talk to me on right down to the least probably. Then I start at the prime. For the people who don’t need to speak, I’ll attempt to speak to their associates, so their buddies will inform them I’m not as scary as they assume I am.

Especially in a small city, and this occurs to me all the time, I don’t know all the totally different rivalries and friendships. Typically that can work to your advantage because they’ll say, ‘Oh, you talked to Dave? All right, I’ll speak to you, because every thing that comes out of his mouth is a lie.’ So, typically it doesn’t need to be speaking to their pals that helps. It may be speaking to their enemies.

How have you learnt whenever you’re ready to write down?

I all the time feel like I’m getting actually close to the writing process when individuals start asking me about what I do know. Or once I get to individual No. 28,  they usually start telling me what occurred that day, and I’m barely writing something down as a result of I already realize it. So I get to some extent where I feel if I hold reporting with out getting some of this down, I’m going to lose it. The deadline strain undoubtedly elements in. That strain may be really robust. Some of these tasks take a very long time, in order that they better be good.

Do you begin writing when you’re nonetheless reporting, or not?

No. I know I’m ready to write down once I know what the top of the story is. Then I feel like the remainder of the story is making an attempt to get to the top. I can’t conceptualize it until I’m pretty far down the street of reporting. I do take actually in depth notes that go into this monster outline. I’m not even positive an overview is the appropriate word as a result of I principally put every part into one monster document that I can word-search; it’ll be my notes from every interview and quotes that I need to use.

Do you’ve got any set time for writing or a place where you write? How do you cope with the stress of writing, especially as you get nearer to deadline?

It’s greatest if there’s some way that I can simply start first thing within the morning and never plunge into e mail, not get distracted by stuff that’s happening. Until I’ve just completed a story, I don’t have lunch with individuals. I don’t go out for espresso. I’m going into work and simply attempt to get as many phrases out through the day as potential. And typically I wish to go to a espresso shop the place I don’t get onto the Wifi, and I put my telephone away and just type of try to get into the zone.

I’m going into work and simply attempt to get as many words out through the day as attainable.

There’s one espresso shop in my neighborhood that is so loud and full of tech bros; it’s not a pleasing setting. I get so much accomplished there because I just need to be achieved. I put my earplugs in, and I can’t depart till I write nevertheless many phrases.

The opposite thing is going to Barton Springs and swimming and just the coldness of that water. It’s like clearing my head utterly. There’s something about leaping into freezing water to assist with no matter that thing is, where you assume, Oh, you’re by no means going to write down one other good story. You’ll be able to’t do this. You’re going to fail. I’ve plenty of that in my head, and then I get into this frigid water and I’m good.

I imagine you do a number of revising. What does that modifying appear to be?

So the mandate of this job, a mixture of really vivid, immersive narrative writing with public interest, accountability reporting — I’m still learning find out how to fuse those two issues and make it really feel like a seamless narrative. Draw you in with the narrative and maintain you with the accountability stuff. It’s not intuitive to me yet.

I’ll give it my greatest shot. We’ll see what works and what doesn’t. We transfer things round after which the editors give me specific instructions as to what they need me to do. One of many issues I really like about this job is that I really feel like I’m studying each day. It’s a unique sort of storytelling. So we, we go through a number of revisions. The thing that’s nice is my editors are so sensible and we now have good, trusting relationships. I’m capable of show them things that perhaps aren’t fairly prepared, and I’m capable of hear them say to me this isn’t working and we need to do that in a different way.

One of many things I really like about this job is that I feel like I’m learning daily.

Jake Silverstein (former editor of Texas Monthly and now editor of The New York Occasions Magazine) is my editor again. he’s fantastic. And my quick editors are sensible: Tracy Weber at ProPublica and Ilene Silverman on the magazine.

What’s one of the best writing recommendation you’ve gotten?

Skip Hollandsworth as soon as advised me to rewrite a draft taking all of the quotes out. He stated ‘Simply stop relying in your quotes to do the work. And don’t be afraid to say what the guy was considering or what was motivating him to do something in your words as a result of it’s going to be better writing.’ And it was so true. Once you’re taking the quotes out, it’s a must to take ownership of the story.

It’s the primary thing I tell youthful reporters, as a result of especially for those who’re training in a newspaper, you may need a quote virtually each paragraph, right? However in case you’re going to do the enterprise stuff, you need to study to be more of a storyteller.

Most popular articles from Nieman Storyboard